Showing posts with label equality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label equality. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 21, 2019

Hotspots in Equality Revisited


"Leninade" by Jamison Wieser is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 2.0 

On my previous blog post, I discussed economic equality and laissez-faire economics and the successes and failures of those principles. I will discuss these further here.

1. The Failure of Forced Equality
(How and why forcing aspects of absolute equality has failed.)

Wednesday, November 14, 2018

The Forgotten Man


I dug my spurs into my horse’s flanks, urging her forward to cut off the cow before she wandered off the trail, dragging half the herd with her.  She complied but bellowed to let me know she wasn’t happy, and it wasn’t too long before a heifer tried the same thing.  My horse diligently obeyed, though I could feel her heavy breaths as her sides expanded and deflated, moving my legs out and in with each pant.  Her mane was damp and her hide glistened with sweat, but on she went. 

It’s not a perfect parallel, but to coincide with William Sumner’s ideas, we could call this horse “the forgotten horse.”  William Sumner was an American social scientist who taught at Yale during the Gilded Age.  The uprisings of monopolies and flourishing of the middle class starkly contrasted with the life the new immigrants and lower class were living.  Efforts were put forth to hinder the growth of booming businesses and others sought ways to assist the immigrants and lower class.  So what does this have to do with a forgotten horse?

In Sumner’s work, What Social Classes Owe to Each Other, he passionately argues that “every effort to realize equality necessitates a sacrifice of liberty.”  He sees many people working diligently and seeing success, yet the fruits of their labors are laid at the feet of those in poverty.  There is no motive to rise above that condition when “social doctors flock about him, bringing the capital which they have collected from the other class, and promising him the aid of the state to give him what the other had to work for.”  With these circumstances, the social reformers and philanthropists, A and B, dictate what C will do for the poor, D.  And what does he call C?  The Forgotten Man. 

Image Credit: Scale (via mesosyn)

Thursday, September 13, 2018

A Stranger at Home


Coinciding with the Renaissance era was a time of exploration by countries of Europe. In particular, Portugal and Spain pioneered the oceans for "God, gold, and glory", or in other words, for the sake of missions, economic prosperity, and global influence/political dominance. Naturally, their European neighbors followed suit. Today, we often discuss their adventures with a heavy grain of salt and a disdainful tone as we remember the harrowing exploitations that took place. But upon reading French explorer Michel de Montaigne's Of Cannibals, I've come to consider that not every adventurer sought to prey upon third-world countries.

A view of the outside world molds the lens in which we view our own. Just as Montaigne saw cannibalism as less savage than aspects of punishment in his home country, travel can lead us to question our morals and mannerisms. This shapes our identity-- and perhaps most of all, with whom we identify.

While living in Japan last August, I did more than just appreciate their culture-- I adopted it. This isn't meant to sound boastful, but to simply express how I related to certain aspects of their culture more than my own. Dignity, modesty, respect, diligence, politeness, kindness... all inherent parts of Japanese custom, and all values which I prize highly. I felt like a sound wave that had been tuned-in to the correct frequency.


This leads one to ask: did the conquistadors ever relate to the cultural ideals of their captive country better than their homeland? Did explorers ever long to live "tribally", or feel like a fish-out-of-water upon arriving home? Looking forward to the Enlightenment, it seems that the explorations of Europe paved the way for a new humanist empathy to take root in Europe.

Perhaps we'd do well to rethink our assumptions about the explorers. Maybe they, too, became strangers to their homelands, and in turn, propagated tolerance across Europe for the indigenous world. 

Wednesday, September 12, 2018

The Same Skin and Bones

Honestly, I usually duck my head when people start getting heated about politics. Maybe it's a millennial trait I've adopted, maybe it's my dislike of contention or maybe it's because there's almost always some form of a "Type A Jason" guy who appears out of nowhere who's soul purpose is to crush your opinion into smithereens as you breathe in between your sentences. Chill out Jason, you need better deodorant.
A version of Utopia from last century-Robert McCall 1983 Mural, The Prologue and the Promise

So here I am, venturing into this semi-political territory, sans Jason, with a simple question: How can the idea of a Utopian Society cause such different and intense reactions? Stay with me here, there are three different societies I have in mind that have hoped to be structured in a Utopian manner. Communism (is everyone still breathing?) The Latter-day Saint idea of Zion in the millennium and Sir Thomas More's Utopia. Though there are significant differences between the three (euthanasia, marriage and divorce and other social practices in More's Utopia, perfection and justice with Christ reigning in the Latter-day Saint millennium and obvious problems, inequalities and loss of freedoms in communism) they all share the same basic skin and bones idea of societal equality. 

So what is it? Why are some of these talked about in total disgust and some looked forward to? The desire for equality seems benevolent enough, but upon execution history proves it to be impossible. It's been suggested that Karl Marx's vision for communism has never really existed. Playing off of that, would a Utopian society even be possible today? Would it make people happy? Or would it inevitably turn into a Dystopia? Ok Jason, have at it.

Image credit : A version of Utopia from last century-Robert McCall 1983 Mural, The Prologue and the Promise http://www.jomec.co.uk/intercardiff/food-culture/searching-for-utopia