Education, Is it Really My Decision?
They say the
most formative years of decision begins in high school. What if you’re never
given the skills to know how to make those decisions. This begins with the
individuals that have the most sphere of influence upon the next rising
generations, the high school teacher; to whom I write.
Background
In order to have
the ability to navigate the social construct of society, we need to be taught
the skills. When eighteen year-olds are sent off to college/secondary
education, they are expected to have a plan for a career path, to know what
they like, along with the accommodating knowledge of their strengths and
weaknesses. As if we are cradled for eighteen years, taught about these fairytale
“adult responsibilities", then to our surprise, know not the skills necessary to navigate
these decisions. I believe the cure to
having a successful chance to navigate the transitional times of secondary education, is a shift in
focus. From that of a “major” mentality, to an individual development mentally.
A mindset that focuses on the development of well-roundedness.
Principles of Navigation
As the
transition from primary school to secondary school is the front battle lines of
the issue, Dr. Kate Johnstone from Deakin University, gives two insights that
can help students manage this pivotal transitional time. Dr. Johnstone
recognizes the anxieties that come from this transition and suggests that
“support” groups, from, “parents, friends
and teachers is crucial to assist all students make a successful transition”. Fear,
anxiety, feeling estranged from a “major community”, (the group of individuals
who have a declared major, against individuals who may feel left out due to an
undeclared major.), are all factors of children lost during these transitions.
Principle two, Johnstone states, encourages a networked student-teacher
community. That, “teachers and the
broader school community are important support resources for students and
parents alike. They can provide valuable guidance for students…”.
While attending Brigham Young University
(BYU), I faced all of these challenges. Feeling like an outsider, in some form
less valued, due to my undeclared major status. You instantly feel different,
left out of a group, looked down upon and placed in a “subliminal” category
where you don’t have your life figure out; somehow making you less. At a yearly
Academic Seminar, held by the College of Family House and Social Sciences
(FHSS), the main concern discussed, was that of the student-professor pipeline.
Bringing to the forefront that students need to know they have a network
available. That they have mentors available to help them find a career path
right for them.
Well-Roundedness
From the time of the Renaissance we read from Castiglione, The Ideal of the Well-Rounded Man, the
reference from the Greeks is made stating, “that
a man ought to be “well-rounded”, meaning that he should develop every aspect of
his personality”. It is through this development of well-roundedness that
we beginning to understand who we are; along with our dislikes, strengths and weaknesses.
Instead of being told what “major pattern” or path we should be going down;
whether for the prestige or money, we need to find or pick a major that plays
to our roles and our strengths.
Conclusion
Education is
important and can be one of the most important catalysts of direction for our career
path. However, we need to be equip, with the adequate skills that will allow us
to make the “best decisions” for our future. So as it was, let us Ad Fontes, and go "back to the source" of education. That we create these needed support systems of
friends and family that will help guide us, giving us the help needed to coupe
with the hardships found within these transitional times between primary and secondary
education. Let us create these modern-day "Enlightenment Salon" of networks. Opening the door for an internal network system of teachers and professors,
that will give the rising youth generations the necessary resources to not only
achieve their dreams and goals; but, giving them hope, vision, and the tangible
knowledge that they can do whatever they set their minds out to do!
Sources
The Ideal Man of
the Well-Rounded Man by Castiglione. New World History – Kelemen
Wow. Can I give a standing ovation for that conclusion? The pathos is strong with this one. It makes me want to run out and hug all the high schoolers I can find - they CAN do it! And these are great suggestions for how.
ReplyDeleteI did notice that there were a few grammatical errors that clouded your argument in places and could be easily fixed. I especially recommend reviewing the paragraph quoting Dr. Johnstone - her comments appear to support your argument perfectly, but the wandering grammar obscures your exact meaning.
Hey Jake, this was really interesting! The story you brought in really drilled in the idea that we need to figure out what we are best at before coming to college. However, I have a few counterarguments that come into my mind. First, instead of having kids figuring out what they are best at in high school, wouldn’t it better if we were to do it in middle school, or even elementary? The earlier the better, right? Another question that I had while reading your post was, what if you came across something that you bad at and wanted to be better. For example, I’m a budding scientist who sucks at writing. Knowing that I'm a terrible writer, I chose to be a writing minor because I wanted to be better a writer. After taking many writing courses here at BYU, I have noticed a huge growth in my writing and I now I enjoy writing instead of hating it. A suggestion that I have if you were able to rewrite your post, I would add in counterarguments and explain why each point wouldn't be beneficial for the audience to see both sides. Other than that, great post!
ReplyDelete