Showing posts with label plural. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plural. Show all posts

Monday, December 3, 2018

Hot Spots in Linguistics and Editing


                                         https://pixabay.com/en/girl-english-dictionary-study-2771936/

   The feminist movement of the ‘70s caused an awareness of the need for a singular neutral pronoun in the English language. Many other languages have a neutral pronoun for both singular and plural. Pronouns are considered a “closed class” and therefore are not something easily changed. Many attempts were made at creating a new pronoun but none were accepted by the English-speaking world. The easiest solution would be to use “they” as our singular neutral pronoun, but not everyone agrees. The linguist John McWhorter says, “English speakers have been using ‘they’ in the singular for eons.” Regardless of this fact, there is still argument as to whether or not it is acceptable because “they” is a plural pronoun being used for a singular antecedent in a sentence like, “Tell each student to hand in their homework.”

   The “Oxford comma” is still a point of debate in the editing world. The Chicago Manual of Style insists on its use, but other style guides, such as the Associated Press, do not use it. Those who insist on it can prove that if it is not used in a series of items, then there can be confusion as to what the author is trying to convey. 

   Language “death” is a concern in the linguistic world. Many linguists are passionate about saving the languages throughout the world that are dying off at alarming rates. Others feel that there is nothing that can be done about it, and that it appears to be a hopeless task. The world renown linguist David Crystal looks at both sides of this issue in his book Language Death.
Crystal, D. (2000, 2014). Language Death. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge        University Press. 

The issue that I am most passionate about is the need for a singular neutral pronoun. I have been studying linguistics and linguistic change for over five years. The most important thing I’ve learned is than language changes. If we have been using “they” as a singular neutral pronoun for hundreds of years, then why are we still arguing about whether or not we can use it as such? Just because it is technically plural is not reason enough to decide that it can’t also be used as a singular pronoun: we’re already using it that way anyway!