Contract disputes (whether between artists and streaming services, artists and record labels, etc.) are not limited to the music industry, or even to the modern day. Throughout history people have drafted all sorts of agreements, contracts, and treaties to be more beneficial to one party at the expense of another. Sometimes this stems from greed, much like the problematic artist contracts of Spotify, or from some desire for justice after being wronged.
The latter was the case for the Treaty of Versailles, the document that ended World War I, and unintentionally started WWII. The Treaty of Versailles, specifically the Way Guilt Clause found within, was worded in such a way so as to basically punish Germany for the role that they played in the war, forcing them to pay costly reparations, give up some of their land they had gained, and restrict their military power, among other things. These conditions were extremely harsh and Germany tried to negotiate them after some time, but they were hardly given any breathing room by the other countries they were paying. As such, they started the Second World War in an effort to get their punishment repealed.
Thankfully, contract disputes in the present day aren't causing any global-scale wars. However, when people get the short end of the stick from a contract they were hesitant to sign in the first place, especially well-known celebrity musicians, odds are that they will try to fight against it. Thankfully, with the help of their fans, they are often able to make the positive changes that are needed or at least makes changes happen that will eventually lead to their goal. Hopefully, we will actually make sure to read contracts ahead of time and hopefully will get to a point as people where we do not use contracts as a means of personal gain alone.
Image Credit: https://www.iamexpat.nl/career/employment-news/new-dutch-labour-laws-conversion-of-contract-from-fixed-term-to-permanent Public Domain
In a perfect world, we wouldn't need to worry so much about the fairness of contracts, but we live in a world where people tend to watch out more for themselves than for others. My person life has taught me the importance of fair contracts, and I am making improvements for the lives of my children and grandchildren.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if you would consider "Terms and Conditions Agreements" as contracts? Because I think that we live in an age where everything you do is preceded by this "contract" of sorts, telling us what we can and can't do, legal requirements, etc. Perhaps contracts don't necessarily lead to war like you were saying, but our willingness to sign something like Apple's Terms and Conditions without reading it fully so we can access our leisure and entertainment quickly is kind of frightening.
ReplyDelete