I used to live in the U.K., and my first encounter with an Irishwoman is seared into my memory forever. She couldn't have been more than five feet tall, but she was terrifying. It wasn't me, but someone had done something wrong and Ciara was full of an eloquent, hilarious anger the likes of which I had never before seen. I didn't know if I was allowed to laugh, but I definitely wanted to. Thankfully, I never ended up on the receiving end of that vitriol, and she and I ended up becoming really good friends. My relationship with Ciara helped me gain more understanding of these people and how they came to be the way they are.
Poster for a short film based on Swift's essay |
It's no surprise then, that arguable the world's greatest satirist, Johnathan Swift, sprang from Ireland. Swift is brutal in his analysis of government and society at large. His most famous piece A Modest Proposal, suggests that the solution to the famine in Ireland could be as simple as eating their children. It's a genius piece of writing and a scathing critique of Parliament's negligence.
Before the Enlightenment era and the advent of the public forum, the Irish and their unique perspective was confined to their island. But with the popularization of the press and a second swell of individualism, voices bubbled up from all kinds of forgotten places. Voices that become essential in shaping the future.
Photo Credit
Considering your experience with your friend and your observations about the Irish, I can't help but wonder how much of their tendencies are nature vs. nurture? Red-heads have the reputation for having a temper, so how much of that comes from genetics and how much from societal expectation? Of course, both nature and nurture have something to do with it. Knowing this, I wonder if Johnathan Swift, if he had been born elsewhere, would have the same suggestions?
ReplyDeleteThat's a very good point you made--that the press and individualism are what spurred these voices on. Advances in communication are what enabled Swift to write the piece, and it's what allows us to study it today.
ReplyDeleteTHANK YOU FOR WRITING SOMETHING THAT WAS SO FUN TO READ! I loved that you said "pissed" in the first sentence. Truly fabulous. I'm curious about the Irish now, I wonder how much Jonathan Swift was influenced by his culture and how much was just him. Very fun read!
ReplyDelete